My research investigates the epistemic and ethical
dimensions of artificial intelligence engineering: the
philosophical implications of designing, manufacturing,
and deploying autonomous intelligent systems in science
and society.
My current projects extend that work in two main
directions. The first rehabilitates the maker’s
knowledge tradition to explain how making minds advances
cognitive science. The second unpacks what AI engineers
owe everyone else. In both directions I work with two
kinds of tool at once: the careful conceptual analysis
and logical argumentation of philosophy and the
computational methods of artificial intelligence,
including computer simulations, robots, and
large-language-model text analysis.
Papers
Complex Cognitive Systems and the Maker’s Knowledge Tradition
When Does the Body Matter? A Dynamical Signature of
Coupling Dependence in Evolved Neural Controllers
Collin Lucken
From Animals to Animats 18: Proceedings of the 18th
International Conference on the Simulation of
Adaptive Behavior
(SAB 2026), Berlin. Springer Lecture Notes in Artificial
Intelligence, forthcoming
Forthcoming
This paper presents a method for studying how
continuous-time recurrent neural networks regulate
behavior in virtual, highly idealized models of
embodied, evolved agents, or ‘animats’. It
asks the question: what patterns emerge in a simple
animat’s neural dynamics when its sensorimotor
coupling to the environment is severed or manipulated?
The paper proposes three interventions that vary the
incoming perturbations to the animat’s evolved
neural controllers. It then applies these three
interventions across 60 different controllers, evolved
to find and move to a light source in their environment
(i.e. phototaxis). The patterns of neural activity
recorded in the animats during the phototaxis task are
then measured using dynamical systems theory. Networks
that react more to these interventions are described as
those with greater embodiment dependence. In the
analysis, embodiment dependence is found to be
characterized by three largely independent dynamical
dimensions: (1) input-driven amplification of neural
activity, (2) distinctness of neural trajectories
between trials, and (3) metastable-coordination richness
(the number of transient coordination states the network
visits).
Mindshaping and Learner-Centered Pedagogy: A Revealing
Harmony
Collin Lucken & W. John Koolage
Teaching Philosophy, forthcoming
Forthcoming
The mindshaping research program, which is increasingly
gaining attention in human social cognitive science,
centers pedagogy as among the most important components
of human cognition. By centering pedagogy as an
essential social cognitive practice, the mindshaping
research program is uniquely suited as a scientific
framework for philosophy teaching. An explicit
articulation of this connection demonstrates both the
fruitfulness of the mindshaping research program and an
opportunity for philosophy teachers to rethink or refine
their teaching. This paper argues that philosophy
teachers can usefully treat philosophy pedagogy as if it
were a form of mindshaping. Our proposal is that
adopting mindshaping as a ‘lens’ or
regulative frame through which one conceives of
philosophy teaching reorganizes what teachers see when
they look at their own practice. Specifically, we show
that viewing teaching through the lens of mindshaping
conceived as a form of epistemic niche construction
clarifies what good teaching aims to do: shape
learners’ skills and dispositions to build and
inhabit epistemic environments that extend their
cognitive capacities.
Scientific Works and the Transfer of Technique
Collin Lucken
European Journal for Philosophy of Science
Revise and resubmit
Techniques routinely transfer between scientific
domains that share no theoretical framework.
Photolithographic patterning migrates from
semiconductor physics to microfluidics; adaptive optics
moves from astronomy to retinal imaging; cryogenic
vitrification transfers from materials science to
structural biology. Existing philosophical accounts
presuppose that cross-domain coherence requires
theoretical or social mediation. Counter to that
presupposition, I introduce the concept of scientific
works: deliberate material interventions that, by
restructuring an organism-environment system, durably
extend the set of invariants in that system that the
community can reliably exploit. Drawing on
Gibson’s ecological psychology and niche
construction theory, I argue abductively that
scientific works provide the best explanation of
technique transfer. A shared material regularity is
necessary for transfer but not sufficient. Transfer
succeeds when the target domain lies within the range
of transformations across which a technique’s
invariant persists and when the receiving community
restructures its own organism-environment system so as
to exploit that invariant; it fails when either
condition is unmet.
When Does the Body Matter? Separating Input Sensitivity
from Loop Dependence in Evolved Agents
Collin Lucken
Adaptive Behavior
Revise and resubmit
Whether the body is part of cognition or merely a cause
of it turns on an inference from coupling to
constitution that behavioral evidence cannot settle.
This paper asks a prior question: what kind of
dependence on ongoing sensorimotor coupling does a
controller have, and how could one tell? I argue that
the divergence of neural trajectories under open-loop
“ghost” conditions measures only input
sensitivity. Claims of loop dependence need two
counterfactual controls instead: the same perturbation
applied with the loop closed and with it cut, and
substitution of a controller with the agent’s own
steady states but no internal dynamics (its reflex
shadow). I applied these controls to several hundred
recurrent-network agents evolved to find a light with
two sensors or with one, and tested the core claims on a
second, preregistered set. Open-loop networks forget
their initial state and follow their input, the closed
loop compensates for perturbation in every agent, and a
reflex suffices for most two-sensor agents and for no
one-sensor agent. In exploratory analyses, a
frequency-response analysis of each network predicts
which agents need their dynamics. Those agents pair a
nearly flat steady-state map with a strong response at
the frequency of the sensory oscillation their own
movement produces, which is the signature of an ordinary
dynamic compensator. Dependence profiles, however
refined, therefore cannot separate cognitive systems
from controlled ones. The coupling–constitution
question turns on the kind of process involved, and what
these measures contribute is an empirical description of
that process.
History of Philosophy of Science
The Erotetic Logic of William Whewell’s Fundamental
Antithesis
Collin Lucken
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, forthcoming
Forthcoming
Whewell’s Fundamental Antithesis of Philosophy is
a curious feature of his thought, as it seems to serve
as the foundation for his entire system while also
remaining especially mysterious. Recent Whewell
scholarship has taken note of the importance of the
Antithesis for Whewell, appealing to it to explain his
views on necessity (Morrison 1997), induction (Snyder
1997, 2008; Forster 2011, Dethier 2018), and mind (van
der Merwe 2023). Despite its importance, the Fundamental
Antithesis has received relatively little attention
compared to other topics in Whewell’s philosophy
such as those just listed. In this essay, I aim to
rectify that lack of attention. More specifically, I am
concerned with determining how we as Whewell’s
readers should approach his mysterious Antithesis. My
conclusion is that the Fundamental Antithesis is best
understood through erotetics, or the logic of question
and answer. This is opposed to how the Fundamental
Antithesis is most frequently described as being about
mind and world merging.
Engineering, Artificial Intelligence, and the Common Good
An Identity-Based Ethics for Engineering
Collin Lucken
Science and Engineering Ethics, forthcoming
Forthcoming
Engineering ethics education often relies on case-study
methods focused on disaster prevention and professional
codes. Recent work in virtue ethics and professional
identity has begun to develop a possible alternative,
but the philosophical foundations of engineering’s
ethical character remain underdeveloped. This paper
argues that engineering constitutes a morally
significant professional identity: a life-shaping
practice whose internal goods are oriented toward the
development of central human capabilities. Drawing on
Appiah’s identity framework, MacIntyre’s
theory of practices and his account of
compartmentalization, the capability approach as
formalized by Robeyns, and Wolfendale’s
regulative-ideal account of professional integrity, I
analyze engineering identity through institutional
analyses of France’s École Polytechnique
and the United States’ Accreditation Board for
Engineering and Technology (ABET). I argue that
engineering’s normative regulative ideal is the
development of human capabilities, and that this
orientation provides the philosophical grounding for an
identity-based approach to engineering ethics education
that connects ethical development to the cultivation of
engineering character.
This article explores new potentials for productive
dialogue between public engagement with science (PEWS)
and radical embodied cognitive science (RECS). The
concept of participatory sense-making from enactive
cognitive science provides an account of why active,
dialogical engagement in science communication is so
effective. After establishing the connection between
PEWS and RECS, the authors motivate the need for
“participatory cognitive strategies” and
present a case study showing their potential in actively
involving different groups of stakeholders throughout
the development of large-scale AI systems, contributing
to ongoing debates about the meaning of
“democratizing AI.”
Other Work
Dissertation
Engineering Progress in Science
Collin Lucken
PhD Dissertation, University of Cincinnati, 2025
Completed
This dissertation develops an operative account of
scientific progress that foregrounds practical
cognition, material construction, and engineering
alongside traditional intellectual reasoning. I argue
that scientific works—including instruments,
models, calibration routines, and experimental
systems—are epistemically significant achievements
that standard accounts of progress overlook. The
framework reveals how engineering practices generate
distinctive forms of knowledge and contribute to
scientific progress on their own terms.
Under Contract
A Guide for Academic Researchers Conducting Science
Outreach
Melissa Jacquart, Amanda Corris, Andrew Evans, Tim Elmo
Feiten, Collin Lucken & Angela Potochnik
Elements in Public Engagement with Science, Cambridge
University Press